By Bohiney Newsroom | WASHINGTON
The MLB antitrust exemption is facing a new legislative challenge, raising fears in owners’ suites that competition might escape the field and begin affecting the businesses surrounding it.
The Senate Judiciary Committee announcement of the baseball competition bill says Senators Dick Durbin and Mike Lee are backing legislation to repeal baseball’s broad exemption. Introduction is not enactment. For now, the exemption remains available to enjoy another leisurely inning of American legal history.
MLB Antitrust Exemption Reports to Spring Training
At Bohiney’s annual Owners’ Protective Equipment Expo, a league proprietor arrived wearing shin guards, a batting helmet, and a lawyer. He said the lawyer provided the best protection but was harder to fit inside the overhead compartment.
“We love competition,” said the proprietor, Randolph Boxseat. “We put nine employees on the field specifically to participate in it. I don’t see why the rest of the organization should be dragged into their hobby.”
Boxseat described the exemption as a treasured tradition, similar to the seventh-inning stretch and charging enough for parking that the car briefly becomes the household’s most expensive dependent. He offered no economic study supporting the comparison, but did point to a very comfortable chair.
The Rulebook Has a Separate Owner’s Edition
Antitrust law generally addresses restraints on competition. Baseball’s special legal status is a complicated subject, not a magic explanation for every ticket price or labor dispute. Bohiney’s stadium economist, who also sells peanuts, warned against pretending one bill would instantly make a family outing cost pocket change.
“Still,” the economist added, “it’s interesting how often the people praising market discipline would prefer that discipline take place in the next ballpark.” He illustrated the point using two concession stands. Both belonged to Boxseat, which shortened the demonstration considerably.
Fan Donna Bleacher said she had assumed an antitrust exemption was the waiver her husband signed whenever he predicted a winning season. After learning otherwise, she asked whether the exemption had a jersey number and could contribute to the bullpen.
MLB Antitrust Exemption Defends Its Veteran Status
Supporters of special treatment often note how long an arrangement has existed. Bleacher said that argument would also protect the broken seat in her section, a structure that has served generations without once returning to its upright position.
Boxseat urged lawmakers to respect baseball’s pace. A legislative hearing, he suggested, should include several pitching changes, a prolonged review, and an announcer explaining that nothing happening was actually a fascinating strategic development.
The proposal now joins the normal congressional process, where no result should be presumed. Fans can follow its actual progress rather than relying on a celebratory press release or a gloomy prediction from an owner polishing his protective lawyer.
Bleacher said she would welcome competition wherever it improved the game. “But if they put a convenience fee on the free market,” she warned, “I’m bringing my own.”
Satirical disclaimer: This story is entirely a human collaboration between two sentient beings—the world’s oldest tenured professor and a philosophy major turned dairy farmer. Our exemption has requested its own locker. Follow the linked reporting for the news underlying the jokes.
