Displaced Americans Ask If Checkout Is Still 10 A.M.
SAN FRANCISCO, California — Airbnb says it will provide $500 million in funding over five years to support free temporary housing for people experiencing crises. The company has apparently discovered that the most radical innovation in the hospitality business is allowing somebody to sleep indoors without charging them extra for the privilege.
How the Airbnb.org Emergency Housing Program Works
Under the announced Airbnb.org initiative, money tied to regular bookings will help people displaced by disasters, families traveling for medical care and survivors escaping unsafe situations. These stays are free to qualifying guests; the familiar cleaning-fee joke is about ordinary short-term rental culture, not an actual charge imposed on aid recipients. You can read how the nonprofit describes its work at Airbnb.org, and disaster survivors can find federal help through FEMA.
It is a worthwhile commitment, but the contrast is irresistible. America has expensive rents and a short-term rental industry criticized for reducing long-term housing supply. Airbnb’s response includes providing more temporary housing. This is like the umbrella industry opening a foundation for wet people.
The City Hall Presentation
A company presentation at a city hall meeting began with good intentions. “We want everyone to have a safe place to stay,” the presenter said. “Wonderful,” replied a city resident. “For how long?” The presenter shuffled the slides and pointed to the next quarter’s earnings. The minutes record the exchange as “a robust dialogue” and record the presenter’s departure as “exit, stage left, with laptop.”
The Checkout Checklist Problem
Anyone who has rented a vacation property knows the ritual. You pay to stay in somebody’s house, then receive seventeen instructions explaining how to leave it cleaner than you found it. Take out the rubbish. Strip the beds. Start the laundry. Load the dishwasher. Feed the goldfish. Apologize to the goldfish for disturbing its schedule.
Read the Fine Print
The fine print on one host’s printed house rules, photographed by a guest, reads in part: “Please treat the home as you would your own, except cleaner. Quiet hours begin at 9 p.m. Fallen trees are the responsibility of the guest. Kindly rinse the goldfish.” A disaster survivor viewing the checkout checklist asked whether the hurricane debris counted as “excess mess.” The host replied that the storm itself was covered, but the fallen oak tree was technically a late checkout.
Five Stars, With Reservations
A review posted by a guest at one temporary stay gave five stars and a short note: “Great location, lovely bed, host very responsive. Docked nothing for the missing roof, as it let in the stars. Would stay again, ideally not for a reason.” The host replied within four minutes. He thanked the guest and asked him to strip the bed.
Why Temporary Housing Is Not a Housing Fix
Actual emergency housing programs do serious work. Temporary shelter provides a bridge for people who have lost homes or need proximity to medical treatment. The challenge is that bridges work only if there is somewhere stable to reach at the other end. A three-night stay cannot replace a housing market in which working families can afford to live. The Department of Housing and Urban Development publishes the numbers, and they do not read like a brochure.
Housing advocates have raised precisely that broader concern, and Airbnb disputes the idea that its platform is a primary driver of urban unaffordability. Both questions deserve examination: what the charitable program accomplishes and how the wider rental market functions. It is possible to appreciate a useful ambulance while asking why the road has so many potholes.
One city council proposed a comprehensive solution: convert every permanent apartment into a short-term rental, then finance emergency stays for residents who can no longer find permanent apartments. They called it “the housing circle of life” and requested a federal grant for arrows on the diagram.
The best measure of the program will be people safely housed, not the size of the corporate press release. Half a billion dollars is substantial. So is the human problem it is trying to address.
The true luxury in American housing should not be a rooftop pool. It should be knowing where you will sleep next month.
5 Humorous Observations About Airbnb and the Housing Crisis
- Airbnb helps the people who got kicked out of their houses by the thing that kicked everybody out of their houses. That’s like the guy who sets your car on fire, then gives you a free bus pass. And he’s really nice about it.
- The house rules are twelve pages long. Twelve! The Constitution is shorter and nobody had to feed a goldfish.
- Five hundred million dollars. You know what I could do with five hundred million dollars? Not rent an Airbnb. That’s the first thing I’d do. I’d buy a couch and sit on it like a king.
- Every Airbnb has a “cozy” bedroom. Cozy means the bed touches all four walls and the door opens into the bed. It’s not a bedroom, it’s a drawer with a pillow.
- The best thing a person can have in America isn’t a pool or a view. It’s a lease. Someone to say, “See you next month.” That’s it. That’s the whole dream. A guy who says “See you next month” and means it.
